Skip to content
Master Your Money — Mastering Markets

Manipulation of Yuan Exchange Rate Enhances Europe's Dependence on China

Growing trade advantages for China, while Europe's industry struggles to keep pace. This predicament is not solely attributed to the competitiveness of the Chinese, but economists caution that Beijing may be engaging in unscrupulous trading practices.

,   and  Administrator
3 min read
China's Manipulation of Yuan Exchange Rate intensifies Europe's Reliance
China's Manipulation of Yuan Exchange Rate intensifies Europe's Reliance

Manipulation of Yuan Exchange Rate Enhances Europe's Dependence on China

Europe's trade relationship with China is undergoing significant shifts, with the trade balance tilting increasingly in China's favour. This imbalance is primarily attributed to China's industrial overcapacity, subsidies, lack of reciprocal market access, and high tariffs and trade barriers that Europe faces when exporting to China.

Key factors contributing to this situation include China's industrial overcapacity, fuelled by state subsidies, which allows Chinese producers to flood the market with cheap goods, undermining European competitors and expanding China's export dominance. The European Union (EU) has responded by imposing steep duties on Chinese electric vehicles, prompting retaliatory actions from China.

Another significant issue is the imbalance in market access. European firms face significant restrictions entering the Chinese market, while Chinese companies enjoy relatively freer access to European markets. The EU demands more balanced access as a critical step toward fairer trade relations.

Europe's rapid transition to renewable energy has also increased dependence on Chinese solar and wind components, similar to past reliance on Russian fossil fuels. This dependence limits Europe's leverage in trade negotiations.

Geopolitical tensions and tariffs have further worsened the imbalance. European attempts to push back on Chinese practices have been met with retaliatory probes and tariffs, escalating tensions rather than resolving imbalances.

The consequences of this trade imbalance are far-reaching. Growing trade deficits challenge European industrial competitiveness and economic sovereignty. Rising political tensions between the EU and China complicate broader diplomatic relations. Moreover, Europe's green energy transition could potentially be at risk due to supply dependence on Chinese manufacturers.

Possible solutions focus on negotiating greater and more reciprocal market access in China, addressing China's industrial overcapacity, strengthening Europe's domestic industrial base and supply chains in strategic sectors like renewable energy components, and maintaining balanced strategic engagement with China while managing U.S. tariff influences and geopolitical considerations to pursue autonomous European trade policies.

However, progress has been limited. Summits and talks have made little headway, with the EU emphasizing that unless China mitigates overcapacity and opens its market more, maintaining current openness will be difficult. The underlying trade imbalance remains a significant challenge tied to structural economic policies and geopolitical dynamics between the EU and China.

Furthermore, it has been concluded that there is currency manipulation and a significant undervaluation of the yuan against the euro. Between 2020 and 2024, there is an estimated additional demand for yuan of approximately 125 billion euros. Strategies such as "decoupling" or "derisking" are achieving the opposite of reducing dependence on China. The yuan is controlled by China's government as part of a deliberate strategy. The trade distortion can only be mitigated through political measures such as new trade rules or compensatory duties.

In conclusion, Europe's trade imbalance with China is a complex issue rooted in economic policies and geopolitical dynamics. Addressing this imbalance requires a multi-faceted approach, including negotiating market access, addressing industrial overcapacity, strengthening Europe's domestic industrial base, and maintaining strategic engagement with China. The ongoing challenges underscore the need for continued dialogue and cooperation between the EU and China to foster fair and balanced trade relations.

[1] European Commission. (2021). European Union - China: A Strategic Outlook. Retrieved from https://ec.europa.eu/info/publications/european-union-china-strategic-outlook_en

[2] European Parliament. (2020). China - A Strategic Outlook. Retrieved from https://www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/BRIE/2020/661932/IPOL_BRI(2020)661932_EN.pdf

[3] International Monetary Fund. (2021). China: Selected Issues. Retrieved from https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/Country/China/Issues/2021/05/27/China-Selected-Issues-46349

  1. The European Commission's strategic outlook highlights the need for negotiations to secure reciprocal market access in China, a crucial step towards achieving fairer trade relations in business and finance.
  2. The imbalance in finance and industry between Europe and China is exacerbated by China's industrial overcapacity, fuelled by state subsidies, and the significant undervaluation of the yuan against the euro, posing challenges for European industrial competitiveness and economic sovereignty.

Read also:

    Related

    Latest