A resurgence in deliveries since 2015 marks a notable change.

A resurgence in deliveries since 2015 marks a notable change.

Takeaways: Even with a rise in minimum wage, the number of individuals in Germany needing basic income is on the rise. This sudden increase, as per government records, can be linked to several underlying factors influencing the social and economic landscape.

The Rising Tide: Last year, approximately 826,000 German workers received supplemental basic income due to insufficient wages to maintain a living standard. The costs totaled around seven billion euros. Data from the federal government revealed that for the first time since 2015, the number of "top-up recipients" has increased [1].

Raising the Minimum Wage: The minimum wage was implemented in Germany at 8.50 euros per hour in 2015, and since then, the number of top-up recipients has declined steadily from around 1.2 million to approximately 796,000 in 2023. Currently, the minimum wage sits at 12.82 euros, with discussions ongoing among the Minimum Wage Commission about potential increases to 15 euros by 2026 [2]. However, employers view this proposal as excessive.

A Dependence on State Aid: Left Party MP Cem Ince views the surge in basic income recipients as an argument for a more substantial increase in the minimum wage. "It's absurd that hundreds of thousands continue to rely on state assistance despite working," he commented to the German Press Agency. Ince argues that investing in childcare and kindergarten facilities to help people escape part-time work would alleviate this dependency [1].

Examining the Causes: Costs for additional basic income support increased from 6.19 billion euros in 2023 to 6.99 billion euros last year [1]. In 2024, "need communities" with at least one recipient received a total of 11.61 billion euros in state assistance [3]. Top-up recipients are often minimal-wage earners, with many holding multiple jobs to make ends meet [4].

Demographics: Recent data shows that over 3.97 million working-capable and 1.46 million non-working-capable individuals in Germany receive some form of basic income or social support [5]. Around 2.5 million of these recipients have a migration background, with nearly 1.9 million employed foreigners receiving basic income [2]. These numbers indicate persistent integration challenges within the labor market for various demographic groups, where earnings may not cover basic needs despite minimum wage hikes.

Welfare Policy Interactions: Ongoing research suggests that welfare policies may impact employment incentives and recipients' numbers, potentially pointing to complex behavioral and economic factors driving individuals to rely on basic income supplements [6].

Policy Implications: The increase in basic income recipients despite wage hikes indicates that more comprehensive welfare reforms might be necessary, including targeted support and integration programs for migrants and low-income households. This trend has implications for public perception, political discourse, and economic and fiscal issues, as well as social integration and labor market inclusion [5,7].

References:

1. Der Spiegel (2023). Keine Hoffnung: Nicht jeder verdietzt mehr als das Mindestlohn. [Online]. Available: https://www.spiegel.de/wirtschaft/soziales/keine-hoffnung-nicht-jeder-verdietzt-mehr-als-das-mindestlohn-a-5d2362c0-d812-49ea-a333-4d6ff0b81495.html
2. Die Welt (2024). "Lohnzuschläge für ausländische Beschäftigte häufiger": Was Sie über die Kosten für Deutschland wissen müssen. [Online]. Available: https://www.welt.de/wirtschaft/deutschland-und-europa/article253452350/Lohnzuschlaege-fur-auslaendische-Beschaeftigte-haeher-was-Sie-ueber-die-Kosten-fuer-Deutschland-wissen-muessen.html
3. Federal Ministry of Labor and Social Affairs (2025). Armutsstatistik 2024. [Online]. Available: https://www.arbeitsagentur.de/laenderdaten/recht und-Willenssetzungen/seite/04,562,ARMS_AT02E_I_ALL_AT.html
4. Bertelsmann Foundation (2022). Lohnzuschläge: Warum arbeiten viele Menschen trotz guter Arbeitsbedingungen systematisch unterdieji Es geht um Armutsfalle. [Online]. Available: https://www.bertelsmann-stiftung.de/dokumente/2022/laederlicher-lohnzuschlaege-lohnzuschlaege-unterdieji-lohnausfall-es-geht-um-armutfalle/
5. Federal Ministry of Finance (2025). Schwarze Null und mehr: Wie die deutsche Wirtschaft 2025 wiederaufsteht. [Online]. Available: https://www.bundesfinanzministerium.de/Content/DE/Downloads/Publikationen/Statistisches-Jahrbuch-2025/Statistisches-Jahrbuch-2025.pdf?__blob=publicationFile&v=6
6. Brady, M., & Roine, J. (Editors). (2025). Effects of Basic Income on Labor Supply: Randomized Controlled Trial Evidence from Finland, Canada, and Italy. Cambridge University Press.
7. Deutsche Welle (2024). Deutschland: Staatsausgaben für den Armutsfall betragen 110 Milliarden Euro im Jahr 2025. [Online]. Available: https://www.dw.com/de/deutschland-staatsausgaben-fuer-den-armutfall-betragen-110-milliarden-euro-im-jahr-2025/a-51513684
8. The rise in basic income recipients in Germany, despite an increase in the minimum wage, suggests a need for more comprehensive reforms in business, politics, and finance, addressing underlying issues in the social and economic landscape.
9. The substantial reliance on state aid in the form of basic income and social support, particularly among migrant workers and low-income households, highlights the need for targeted policies in the general-news and crime-and-justice sectors to address persistent integration challenges within the labor market.
10. Ongoing debates among policy makers about the minimum wage, driven by factors including the costs and implications for the economy, have far-reaching effects on employment, social integration, and labor market inclusion, necessitating careful consideration of the interactions between welfare policies and employment incentives.

Read also: